Wednesday, October 31, 2018

Musical illusions

Here's the English version of my column on music cognition for the current issue of the Italian science magazine Sapere.

_____________________________________________________________

“In studying [optical] illusions”, writes Kathryn Schulz in her book Being Wrong, “scientists aren’t learning how our visual system fails. They are learning how it works.” What Schulz means is that normal visual processing is typically a matter of integrating confusing information into a plausible story that lets us navigate the world. Colour constancy is a good example: the brain “corrects” for variations in brightness so that objects don’t appear to change hue as the lighting conditions alter. The famous “checkerboard shadow” illusion devised by vision scientist Edward Adelson fools this automatic recalibration of perception.


Adelson’s checkerboard illusion. The squares A and B are the same shade of grey.

In this regard as in many others, auditory perception mirrors the visual. The brain often rearranges what we hear to create something that “makes more sense” – with the same potential for creating illusions. Psychologist of music Diana Deutsch has delved deeply into the subject of musical illusions, some of which are presented on a CD released by Philomel in 1995. Several of these have to be heard through stereo headphones: they deliver different pitches to the left and right ears, which the brain reassigns to create coherence. For example, in the “scale illusion” the notes of two simultaneous scales – one ascending, one descending – are sent alternately to each ear. But what one hears is a much simpler pattern: an ascending scale in one ear, descending in the other. Here the brain is choosing to perceive the more likely pattern, even though it’s wrong.

Another example reveals the limitations of pitch perception. A familiar tune (Yankee Doodle) is played with each note assigned a random octave. It sounds incomprehensible. The test shows that, in deciphering melody, we attend not so much to absolute pitch class (a C or D, say) as to relative pitch: how big pitch jumps are between successive notes. Arnold Schoenberg’s twelve-tone serialism ignored this, which is why the persistence of his “tone rows” is often inaudible.

Perhaps the strangest thing about optical illusions is that we enjoy them, even if – indeed, because – we find them perplexing. Instead of being upset by the brain’s inability to “get it right”, we are apt to laugh – not a common response to wrongness, although it’s actually how a lot of comedy works. You might, then, expect to find musical illusions put to pleasurable use in music, especially by jokers like Mozart. But they are rather rare, maybe because we simply won’t notice them unless we see the score. Something like the scale illusion is used, however, in the second movement of Rachmaninov’s Second Suite for Two Pianos, where two sets of seesawing notes on each piano are heard as two sets of single repeated notes. It seems likely that Rachmaninov (not noted for jocularity) wasn’t just having fun – it’s merely easier to play these rapid quavers using pitch jumps rather than on the same note.

6 comments:

Video Sange said...

INFO FREECHIPS TERBARU
INFO FREECHIPS
INFO FREECHIPS POKER
INFO FREECHIPS BOLA
INFO JUDI ONLINE TERPERCAYA
PASANG IKLAN

Mas Bewok said...

Situs aman terpercaya dan tanpa robot? Langsung saja kunjungi situs Poker Online
Poker Online merupakan situs yang terbukti aman dan terpercaya, dengan berapapun kemenangan anda akan dibayar!!
cqzscience
evqtravel
fzchome
gskhealth
hvpbusiness

Della said...

Selanjutnya The Cheating Game menggantikkan kedudukan Card Sharp yang saat itu sangat populer sebagai jenis permainan kartu 3-Mother di sirkuit perjudian kartu poker.
asikqq
dewaqq
sumoqq
interqq
pionpoker
bandar ceme
hobiqq
paito warna
http://199.30.55.59/sumoqq78/
data hk 2019

sports said...

Live Cricket
Play & Win unlimited money in this biggest t20 cricket season going on, just by giving prediction on simple questions by observing the live cricket. Its a real cricket game, so install and convert your fun into real money

prince said...

satta king om pari jamo jamo or pari taki tuka jamo jamo hura huraplay bazaar Mui cho nama kii jaka taki gona pino tika honi raki to pika hojo ka tani mo ra toko pani jake hona chi po honi ga jaki tora pani ka teko ra mino laki jopo mana

Minat Jesisca said...

BONUS YANG TERSEDIA :
* BONUS NEW MEMBER 20%
* BONUS NEXT DEPOSIT 5% ( TERBARU )
* Bonus Turn Over Mingguan 0.5% (ALL GAME TANPA SYARAT)
* BONUS REFERAL BERJALAN TERBESAR ( BONUS DOUBLE )

AYO DAFTARKAN DIRI ANDA SEKARANG JUGA & IKUTI BERBAGAI MACAM EVENT-EVENT MENARIK LAINNYA!!

Untuk Informasi lebih lanjut silahkan hubungi :

WA : +855887950794
Line : minatpoker
Facebook : Cathy Gerald Tan

minatpoker
dewapoker
pokeronline

Agen IDN Poker Online
Bonus Poker Terbesar
Poker Online Indonesia
Situs Poker Online Terpercaya
Agen IDN Play Terbaik